If four years of blogging about television has taught us anything, it’s that everybody’s a critic. Which is why, as much as we hate to be the one to rain on the SUPERNATURAL fandom’s parade — a fandom that deserves serious credit for mobilizing their troops in a successful bid to win TV Guide Magazine’s first ever Annual Fan Favorite Poll — we can’t help but echo the sentiments commentor Kelly who characterized the Magazine’s cover as “Way too 90210 and not nearly enough Winchester.”
Suffice to say, Jared [Padelecki] doing his best impersonation of a vapid male model, and Jensen [Ackles] channeling his inner Derek “Blue Steel” Zoolander doesn’t quite get across the message that these two demon-hunting butt-kicking brothers have saved the world from annihilation on more than one occasion. Cue… Extreme Makeover: TV Guide Magazine Edition.
Think you have the artistic chops to design a cooler cover? Now’s your chance to prove it! Simply download the design elements posted below and send your Extreme Makeover by December 17th, 2010 to danielthetvaddict [at] gmail [dot] com. Submissions will then be posted on December 20th giving readers the opportunity to vote for their favorites with the winning cover artist walking away with a copy of SUPERNATURAL: THE COMPLETE FOURTH SEASON on Blu-ray. 
Click here to download Supernatural.psd.zip, and please note that the copy is merely a guideline and can of course be changed to suit the needs of your design.