The TV Addict 

SHOULD WIN: Jon Hamm

I wouldn’t mind a win by Cranston or Hall, and Spader has given some funny acceptance speeches. But I am so over Hugh Laurie! I think he – and his sometimes gimmicky show – are both overrated.

WILL WIN: Jon Hamm

SNUBBED: Kyle Chandler

James Spader? James Freak’n Spader? Did he buy a five year pass or something? Every year I see his name on there I have spasms. I’ll never get it.

I totally agree about how much Hugh Laurie deserves to win and how much the strength his performance makes his co-stars virtually irrelevant. He’s my first choice to win. Of course, I only watch two out of the six shows these actors are in, so I guess I’m biased by default.

And, I know this won’t be a popular opinion, but I may be the only person in the solar system who’d actually be okay with James Spader winning too. Boston Legal’s first three seasons were hit & miss, but season four was its best year, thanks to the show’s best combination of characters, sharp writing, and excellent performances, most of them coming from James Spader.

The strength of Boston Legal comes from two main elements: Alan Shore’s long closing arguments and the cigar & chat sessions between Alan and Denny Crane (William Shatner) that close each episode. I’m always impressed with the writing & acting during Spader’s excessively long monologues which are always full of poignancy, humor, and social commentary all at the same time. He can go from energetic, ranting, and cynical to quietly and almost sorrowfully passionate in a blink. And, I love his character’s chemistry with Denny Crane, even though I’ve read that Shatner may not like Spader much in real life.

Also, Emmy votes for acting are based on a single episode, not a full season. Spader is nominated for the episode in which his character passionately and aggressively pled a case to the U.S. Supreme Court. It was one of the best 3 or 4 episodes of the season, probably one of the best ten of the whole series, and one of the character’s best closing arguments ever. No matter what Spader was like the rest of the season, he’s deserving for this episode.

That’s why I think Candice Bergen and, yes, even William Shatner are both deserving in their supporting nominations too. They are also nominated for their respective best episodes. Fair or not, David E. Kelley knows how to write episodes specifically with Emmy nominations in mind.

Should Win: Hugh Laurie

Will Win: Jon Hamm

(We think alike, TVAddict.)

Snubbed: Jensen Ackles

[...] Lead Actress in a Comedy Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Outstanding Drama Outstanding [...]